Best Pizza in NYC | 10 Must-Try Spots in 2025 and What to Order

Reading time: 12 minutes

If there’s one thing New Yorkers are passionately opinionated about, it’s pizza. From street corner slices to wood-fired artisan pies, the city’s pizza scene is an ever-evolving masterpiece. In 2025, finding the best pizza in NYC isn’t just about taste—it’s about tradition, texture, toppings, and that unbeatable New York attitude. Whether you're craving a classic New York style pizza slice or something more avant-garde, this guide dives deep into the best pizza places in NYC, what to order, and why each spot earns its fame.

Why Is New York Style Pizza So Famous?

New York style pizza is beloved for its large, foldable slices with a thin yet chewy crust. It’s a culinary symbol of the city—hand-tossed dough, fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and baked in ultra-hot ovens for that perfect crunch. This pizza style rose to prominence thanks to Italian immigrants in the early 1900s, and today, it’s recognized worldwide. What sets the best New York pizza apart is its simplicity, portability, and iconic flavor.

But there’s more to the story. The water in New York City is often credited as a secret ingredient that enhances the dough’s flavor and texture, giving New York pizza its signature bite. Many pizzerias even claim that the mineral composition of NYC tap water is impossible to replicate, which is why some out-of-state pizza shops ship it in to mimic the original taste.

Moreover, the culture surrounding pizza in NYC plays a huge role in its fame. Whether it's grabbing a slice after a late night out or debating which borough has the best pizza places in NYC, pizza is deeply woven into the fabric of New York life. The accessibility of a good slice on nearly every block also sets New York apart. It’s not just a food—it’s a lifestyle.

In recent years, the evolution of toppings, artisanal techniques, and even the resurgence of traditional methods have kept New York pizza fresh and relevant. From trendy spots reinventing old classics to legacy shops maintaining century-old recipes, the best pizza in New York strikes a perfect balance between innovation and authenticity. And that's what makes it truly iconic.

Top 10 Famous Pizza Places in 2025 Serving the Best Pizza in NYC

New York City is home to some of the best pizza places in NYC, where each slice tells a story of tradition, innovation, and pure pizza love. Whether you're a lifelong resident or visiting for the first time, these 10 famous pizza spots have earned their place in the city's vibrant pizza scene. Here's a look at the best pizza in NYC in 2025 and the must-try pies at each location.

1. Joe’s Pizza – Greenwich Village

What to Order: Classic Cheese Slice – $3.50
Quick Tip: A NYC staple since 1975—don’t miss it.
Joe’s Pizza is a classic, quintessential slice of New York pizza. Founded in 1975, it’s one of the best pizza places in NYC for those craving a traditional New York style pizza slice. The thin crust, tangy tomato sauce, and perfectly melted mozzarella have made Joe’s a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. Whether you’re grabbing a slice for lunch or enjoying a late-night bite, Joe’s serves up some of the best pizza NYC has to offer, and its consistent quality makes it a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

2. Prince Street Pizza – SoHo

What to Order: Spicy Spring Square Slice – $5.00
Quick Tip: Go early to avoid long lines.
Known for its iconic thick crust and generous toppings, Prince Street Pizza is a hotspot for the best pizza in New York. The Spicy Spring Square Slice is a fan favorite, with spicy pepperoni cups that crisp up beautifully in the oven. This beloved pizzeria in SoHo is often lined up with visitors eager to try one of the best pizza places in NYC. The combination of texture, flavor, and seasoning makes it a standout choice for those looking to experience the best pizza in NYC in 2025.

3. Lucali – Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

What to Order: Plain Pie – ~$30
Quick Tip: No reservations, BYOB, cash only.
Lucali is where tradition meets perfection. Famous for its New York style pizza, Lucali offers a simple yet outstanding plain pie that speaks volumes about the pizzeria’s commitment to quality. With a slightly charred crust and fresh, high-quality ingredients, Lucali has earned its reputation as one of the best pizza places in NYC. While the no-reservation policy may deter some, the wait is well worth it for a taste of this Brooklyn gem.

4. Di Fara Pizza – Midwood, Brooklyn

What to Order: Regular Round Pie – $30
Quick Tip: Expect a wait; worth every second.
At Di Fara Pizza, you’re not just getting a pizza; you’re getting a piece of history. Founded by Domenico DeMarco in 1964, Di Fara has become synonymous with the best pizza in NYC. Every pie is made with imported ingredients and carefully crafted by the hands of a pizza legend. Whether it’s the classic New York pizza or the more experimental pies, Di Fara’s consistency and quality are unmatched. Prepare for a wait, but know that it’s all part of the experience. For pizza lovers seeking the best pizza in New York, Di Fara is a pilgrimage worth making.

5. John’s of Bleecker Street – West Village

What to Order: Margherita Whole Pie – ~$21
Quick Tip: No slices—whole pies only!
A staple of famous pizza NYC, John’s of Bleecker Street has been serving coal-fired pizzas since 1929. Known for its crispy, charred crust and authentic New York style pizza ingredients, this pizzeria is one of the best places to experience traditional New York pizza. Whether you go for the classic Margherita or the pepperoni, every bite from John’s is a reminder of why it’s considered one of the best pizza places in NYC. The coal-fired ovens are key to producing a crisp crust that is both smoky and slightly charred, elevating the flavor to new heights.

6. L’Industrie Pizzeria – Williamsburg, Brooklyn

What to Order: Burrata Slice – $5.50
Quick Tip: Their toppings are seasonal and photogenic.
Located in Brooklyn’s trendsetting Williamsburg neighborhood, L’Industrie Pizzeria has quickly become one of the best pizza places in NYC. Their Burrata slice is a standout—loaded with creamy burrata cheese, seasonal toppings, and a perfectly crispy crust. The inventive use of fresh ingredients and creative seasonal pies make this pizzeria a favorite for those seeking something new while still enjoying the essence of New York style pizza. The vibe is laid-back, making it a great spot for both pizza lovers and foodies looking to try the best pizza in NYC.

7. Scarr’s Pizza – Lower East Side

What to Order: Sicilian Slice – $4.50
Quick Tip: Cool retro vibes and high-quality ingredients.
Scarr’s Pizza on the Lower East Side is a throwback to the classic New York pizzerias of yesteryear, with a modern twist. Known for its crispy, delicious Sicilian slice, Scarr’s takes pride in using top-quality ingredients, including house-milled flour. This commitment to quality has earned it a spot among the best pizza places in NYC. The retro décor, high-end ingredients, and dedication to craft make Scarr’s a standout in a city full of great pizza. If you’re a fan of famous pizza NYC, this spot should be at the top of your list.

8. Patsy’s Pizzeria – East Harlem

What to Order: Margherita Pie – ~$20
Quick Tip: A historic gem from 1933.
Established in 1933, Patsy’s Pizzeria is one of the oldest and most iconic pizza places in NYC. Known for its coal-oven pizzas, Patsy’s serves up some of the best pizza in New York, with its crispy, thin crust and classic topping combinations. The Margherita pie, with its fresh mozzarella and tangy tomato sauce, is a favorite among regulars and visitors alike. If you’re exploring the pizza scene in East Harlem, make sure to stop by this historic pizzeria to enjoy a taste of famous pizza NYC.

9. F&F Pizzeria – Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

What to Order: White Pie Slice – $5.00
Quick Tip: Tucked beside Frankies 457—great neighborhood stroll.
A hidden gem in Brooklyn, F&F Pizzeria serves some of the most unique and flavorful pies in the city. Their White Pie Slice is a favorite, with a rich, creamy base and fresh, seasonal toppings. Whether you're a long-time pizza enthusiast or a newcomer to the best pizza in NYC, F&F offers a fresh take on the classic New York pizza experience.

10. Motorino – East Village

What to Order: Brussels Sprouts Pizza – $19
Quick Tip: Ideal for dine-in and date nights.
Known for its Neapolitan-style pizza, Motorino offers an elevated pizza experience in the heart of the East Village. The Brussels sprouts pizza, with its perfectly balanced flavors, is one of the most unique and delicious pies in NYC. For those looking for a romantic date night or an intimate dining experience, Motorino’s cozy setting and exceptional pizzas make it one of the best pizza places in NYC.

5 Delicious Styles of New York Pizza You’ve Got to Try

1. Neapolitan

Characterized by its soft, chewy crust and blistered edges, Neapolitan pizza is the foundation of NYC’s pizza roots. Typically baked in wood-fired ovens at high heat. Its origins trace back to Naples, Italy, but the New York version often features locally sourced mozzarella and unique topping blends that give it a more urban edge. Places like Motorino and Song E Napule offer authentic Neapolitan flavors with that NYC twist.

2. Sicilian

Thick, fluffy, and square-cut, Sicilian pizza offers a different texture and taste—crispy on the bottom and airy on top. Traditionally topped with tomato sauce beneath the cheese to prevent sogginess, it’s a hearty slice that’s both comforting and filling. It’s especially popular for lunch crowds and big family-style orders. Famous versions can be found at L&B Spumoni Gardens and Scarr’s Pizza.

3. Coal-Oven

Cooked in coal-fired ovens for a smoky flavor and a perfectly charred crust. A favorite for old-school pizza lovers, coal-oven pizza is all about technique and timing. The high heat (upwards of 800°F) creates a unique balance between crunch and chew. Establishments like John’s of Bleecker and Lombardi’s are legendary for serving this traditional take on the best pizza in NYC.

4. Thin-Crust New York Slice

The most iconic—large, foldable, and dripping with mozzarella. It’s what defines famous pizza NYC. Known for its slightly crisp exterior and chewy interior, this slice is designed to be eaten on the go. Whether you're at Joe’s Pizza in Manhattan or Best Pizza in Williamsburg, this style reigns supreme.

5. Creative/Modern Toppings

From burrata to truffle oil and even Brussels sprouts, the best pizza NYC now blends tradition with innovation. Many places highlight seasonal and locally sourced toppings. Some spots are even embracing plant-based cheeses and gluten-free doughs to cater to modern dietary needs. Creative toppings transform pizza into a gourmet experience, with restaurants like L’Industrie and Rubirosa leading the charge.

Create Your Own NYC Pizza Tour

For pizza lovers on a mission, a DIY tour of the best pizza in New York is a must. Start in Greenwich Village with Joe’s Pizza, head to SoHo for Prince Street’s spicy square, then hop a train to Brooklyn for Lucali and Di Fara. Whether you're staying in Manhattan or exploring boroughs like Brooklyn and Harlem, a slice (or a whole pie) is never far. Use your pizza adventure to explore neighborhoods, from the trendy streets of Williamsburg to the retro charm of the Lower East Side.

Finalmente…

Whether you're a lifelong New Yorker or a first-time visitor, finding the best pizza in NYC is a journey worth savoring. Each neighborhood, oven, and pizzaiolo brings something special to the table. From the cheesy comfort of a classic New York style pizza slice to innovative pies that push culinary boundaries, NYC’s pizza game in 2025 is stronger than ever. Hungry yet? Lace up your walking shoes, bring some cash, and prepare to experience the best pizza in New York—one slice at a time.